While there are many restaurants in Gettysburg that I'm sure are worthwhile that I've not listed here, this list includes places that I can personally recommend from experience. Facebook links (restaurant name) and website links are included. (Last updated 01/11/25.)
• Pizza/Subs
Their diced tomato, feta, and jalapeño pizza is the best pizza in town.
• Pub/Bar
Sign of the Buck
29 Chambersburg Street
Website
The best of both tavern and upscale foods. Very reasonably priced lunch options, and in a time of fewer Sunday brunches, don’t forget that option, too.
The Garryowen Irish Pub
126 Chambersburg St
Website
Appalachian Brewing
259 Steinwehr Ave
Website
Appalachian feels a bit like a larger chain, but you’ll find some nice food and drink selections.
• Mexican
Montezuma
225 Buford Avenue
Website
• Italian
La Bella Italia
402 York Street
Website
Waitstaff can sometimes be overtaxed, but the food is good if you’re not in a hurry.
• Diner/American
Food 101
101 Chambersburg Street
Website
Gettysburg Baking Company
17 Lincoln Square
Website
• Upscale
Dobbin House Tavern
89 Steinwehr Avenue
Website
• Not in Gettysburg, But Close Enough...
Gateau Monique Bakery
5 South Queen Street, Littlestown
Website
Scones, cupcakes, cheesecake, tarts, you name it... you'll love it here. Worth a morning drive from wherever you're at.
C&D Bar & Grill
6465 York Road, New Oxford
Website
Inn 94
4805 Carlisle Pike, New Oxford
Website
In the neighbrohood of nearby Hanover? If so, pick up some Hanover suggestions by clicking here.